Which orientation is the more pleasent for viewing?

[Horacio]

This scene of yachts reflected in the water was taken today. I would like to know your opinion about the right viewing orientation. Thanks.

[Tom Holle]

Re: Which orientation is the more pleasent for viewing?

I like the first one best, don't know why.

[Pol]

Re: Which orientation is the more pleasent for viewing?

I prefer the first one.

They're both pleasant to look at and my initial reaction was that the second one was easier on the eye. However, after studying both for quite a while, I noticed that the point where the tree meets the water makes the water appear to be 'upside down' in the second image.

So it has to be the first image every time for me.

Pol

[Autumn]

Re: Which orientation is the more pleasent for viewing?

I also prefer the first one, but the second makes a nice abstract.