Wildebeest, Here I come, Ready or Not...

[coupekid]

Re: Wildebeest, Here I come, Ready or Not...

Jolly good. A fine record. Don't alter and don't listen to advice on composition. You grabbed it as it happened, thats the important thing.

Are you suggesting that my advice is poor regarding the composition Nitfie?

Do you prefer the original shot on this thread?

[Ian]

Re: Wildebeest, Here I come, Ready or Not...

Are you suggesting that my advice is poor regarding the composition Nitfie?

Do you prefer the original shot on this thread?

Ben, I think he's responding to a version that is less cropped than the first version that started the thread. My take is that he's agreeing with in saying 'don't crop'

Ian

[lourensb]

Re: Wildebeest, Here I come, Ready or Not...

In fairness the OP (Lou) asked about cropping in the full image. I don't want to get involved in semantics but cropping the original results in the final composition. I'd suspect that so far as composition in the camera is concerned there was very little, Lou just pointed the camera as quickly as possible and shot the image. With respect, the implication of your comment was that no heed should be made to any advice about composition and therefore the cropping. I therefore commented that this advice had resulted in a better image. I hope that makes sense

This is Exactly the Point Yes, Thanks Stephen.

For me, Even Croping the Original, to get a Better "Composition" is the Way, To get a Composition. Even if its not the Original Shot Out of the Camera.

Of Late, I take Fotos, "without caring" if you can Call it that, about a stone, or rock that might fall just within the Boundrais, Because I will Crop it, To get a Better "Composition"

And this is Somethin I strugle with, And Everyone here, Are most Helpfull in this regard.

And I believe By following their Advice, You can Get very far with this.

So lets not Argue or Debate this Matter OF Cropping, or Composing, I am also kind off at fault, by Posting the Edited Versions In the Same Post, as People Might not then look at the Original, and Then Don't Agree on the Comments made..

Once Again, Thanks to all for sound Advice. It Sure helps me to get a little better understanding..

Lou

[Autumn]

Re: Wildebeest, Here I come, Ready or Not...

Thanks, I Did take note of this,

Here is The Final Entry then . Thank you for all your Help.



Edited, And Decided to Add Final Image.

I just love this less saturated and virtually uncropped shot Lourensb